Dark, Obsessive Cravings ~ [Sub4Dom search, All Gender Pairings Welcome]

Hey! Welcome to my search thread. I'm in my early 20s, female, and have been writing and roleplaying for about 12 years.

To preface everything here, I want to put a bit of a content warning. I am looking for VERY dark plots mostly set in modern/realistic settings, and all of them will involve noncon and taboo subjects in some way. Most of them involve kidnapping, the ones that don't do have blackmail. This search is pretty much 100% smut-horror focused and any of these plots could be short or long term.

What I want from you:

- Willing to play doms, especially if they're evil, bonus points if they're greasy.

- Able to reply pretty quickly- I'm hoping for 1+ reply a day, at least at the start. I don't mind slowing down or even dropping the RP entirely if we lose -interest or get busy. I'm ghost friendly but prefer a message if possible.

- Able to write a range of post lengths depending on the situation.

- 3rd Person/past tense, private roleplays only!

- No AI usage for faceclaims, please. It takes me out of the RP.

What I bring to the table:

- Willing and able to play fun subs- not doormats, but not impossible to wrangle. I want to give you a challenge. If you want a specific personality, let me know.

- Able to reply fairly quickly, sometimes multiple times per day, but am able to be flexible and will try to warn you if I have to take a break. I will probably slow down here and there as I'm very busy irl.

- Responses can vary from 10 paragraphs for starters or 2-3 for snappy back and forths. I like post lengths to be variable depending on the situation, it doesn't always make sense to churn out 1000 words for a conversation response.

- I will almost always find art to use as a face claim, I don't really like using real photos for mine.

- 3rd person/past tense, private roleplays only

- I can change my character's appearance a bit to match your preferences, but I generally tend to prefer to keep it at least in the realm of realism.

- I can play any gender. I do prefer cis female characters as that's what I have the most experience in.

Now onto the spicy stuff~

My preference sheet is linked! That'll lead you to the Big List, but I'll put a tl;dr here:

Faves:

Bondage

Kidnapping/Blackmail

Noncon/Dubcon

Praise and Degradation

Master/Pet and Master/Slave

Hard Nos:

Death

Real-life Racism

Mutilation/Torture

Toilet Stuff

Ageplay

Mind Control

CURRENT PLOTS/CRAVINGS!

These are ordered in roughly my preference/craving order! I have put suggested gender pairings on them, but I could be convinced to do other gender pairings with basically any of them. These are all just skeletons and can be fleshed out as a joint effort!

~MODERN PLOTS~

~Adopt Don't Shop~

Main kinks: kidnapping, Master/Pet, bondage, stalking, cages, gags

Pairing: A x F 

YC has been obsessed with MC for a while. He's kept it quiet, of course–they can't risk scaring her off. But they've been planning this for a long, long, time: getting measurements, buying toys and accessories, getting a kennel ready…everything you do when you're preparing to get a new pet. And now, finally, everything is ready for her.

MC, an office worker, doesn't expect to be fired when she comes into work. She doesn't expect to find an eviction notice on her door when she goes back home. And she certainly doesn't expect to find herself being jumped from her own closet and dragged off to a secluded house by someone she doesn't remember ever meeting.

For this one I would like the obsessiveness from YC to be focused pretty much solely on MC's looks. In fact, MC could be gagged or muzzled for most of this RP and that would be perfectly fine. I want to explore a dynamic where YC isn't interested at all in romance or a human connection with MC–the 'pet' part of this master/pet dynamic is pretty important. They want something he can train and order around, something that can't speak or leave or resist, and they chose MC purely because she was exactly their type physically.

Interestingly, I feel like this rp could also work with no sex at all, though I know that's a hard sell. I just want to dive really deep into the "human pet" idea and explore the process of breaking MC down from a person to YC's pet.

~Squatter's Rights~

Main kinks: bondage, gags, drug use, size difference, sex toys

Pairing: AxF

YC is a recently-escaped convict. They flee deep into the woods where they find a nice, big summer home. It's clearly owned by some rich bastard, but it also hasn't been touched in a while…so they break in and make themself at home.

MC is the estranged daughter of a rich CEO who recently passed away. His summer home was passed to her in his will- probably by accident- and she's come over to clean it out and inspect it. What she doesn't expect to find is some random person living it up in the home.

YC freaks out when they're seen by her and jumps her, stopping her from leaving and quickly subduing her so she can't run off and report them to the police.

YC is not a good person. They never were, and never will be. It's not hard for them to decide that she's not leaving--and they're going to have a lot of fun with her while she's stuck here. The best part is that she's just become independently wealthy, so they can use her money to buy them food, keep the lights on, and get some better restraints for their new plaything. And some toys to keep them both entertained, of course.

For this one I think it would be fun if YC was very physically strong and tall. Just really enhance this power dynamic. Also, some makeshift bondage will be fun with this, at least at first--using tape, belts, clothing, creative furniture use, that kind of thing.

~Old Man's New Dog~

Main kinks: pet play, kidnapping, cages, age gap, size difference 

Pairing: MxA

For this I would love if you played a large older man (in his 50s-60s). I would love if he was a bit "slovenly"- lives in a messy old house, smokes inside. Bonus points if he's a bit overweight. He lives in a rural area, isolated from most people.

MC's car breaks down near his property and they hike up to his place to ask for help. He agrees and invites them in out of the cold. When they step in, though, they get hit on the back of the head and black out.

When they come to, they've been locked in a dog kennel barely big enough for them to be on all fours with a collar around their neck, dressed in completely different clothes (or none at all). He's crashed their car somewhere to make it look like they're dead. He retired recently, after all, and he's terribly lonely after his old dog died. He's so excited to have a replacement pup- and they're such a pretty young thing to play with and keep him company, too!

~Double Date~

Main kinks: kidnapping/blackmail, master/slave and master/pet, pet play, slutty clothes, bondage 

Pairing: MxFxF

YC is sick of the dating scene. He can't keep a girl around to save his life and he's tired of pouring in effort to receive little in return. Sure, he's had a few good girlfriends in the past. MC1 was a fun, adventurous fling, but she was afraid of commitment and didn't like to settle down. That little slut ran off on him for a hotter guy as soon as she got the chance. MC2 was hot and quiet- just his type- but she was so shy and serious, she wouldn't let him fuck her until marriage and then she left him before he could even propose. The others weren't worth remembering.

He'd just meant to take and keep one, it's just…he couldn't decide. Both were easy targets, and they could fulfill different roles for him. MC1 needs discipline. She needs a firm hand and punishment for stepping out of line, so he decides she can be his slave. MC2 needs praise and guidance, so she can be a pet--he always thought she'd look good on her knees. Every household worth its salt needs a submissive wife and a family pet, after all. So why not both?

YC blackmails MC1 with her old naked pictures into meeting him in a secluded area where he knows MC2 likes to take walks and uses her to lure in MC2. Once he has them in his grip, he takes them home with him and turns them into his perfect pair.

This one will probably be pretty bondage-heavy and involve some double bondage (like tying the girls together), and having them perform acts on each other as well as him.

~Robbery Gone Wrong~

Main kinks: blackmail, master/slave, bondage, age gap, slutty clothes

Pairing: AxA 

YC is a rich CEO on the verge of retirement. They're also an army veteran. This combination means that when MC, a young homeless person desperate for money, makes the very foolish decision to break into their home to steal their valuables, they're caught, subdued, and restrained by YC incredibly quickly.

YC takes MC's ski mask off and sees a young, pretty, desperate thing underneath, so they cut them a deal: YC won't go to the police with this, as long as MC stays here with YC as their slave. It's not for forever, YC promises. Just for as long as their prison sentence would be- about 15 years, but maybe MC can get that sentence lower with good behavior. If MC doesn't agree, well…YC has cameras, and they promise to throw the book at MC with everything they've got.

With the choices being a stint of potentially very comfortable sexual slavery or life in a terrible prison, MC agrees.

This could be a fun long term one with MC earning more and more freedom and privileges for good behavior. YC would make sure they are being very well taken care of, even pampered, but also being forced to do things they wouldn't otherwise--like going shopping with YC in bondage under their clothes, giving YC oral under their desk at work, or serving YC's rich houseguests at a Christmas house party while in Christmas lingerie.

I think this could be a very fun femdom game but any gender pairing works.

~No Witnesses~

Main kinks: kidnapping, cages, bondage

Pairing: AxA

YC is a serial killer who operates under a strict set of rules and picks their victims very carefully. They do a lot of research every time and thus have never been caught. Half of their murders are still deemed as missing persons. Some are deemed as natural causes. There's very little heat on their tail.

Why they're doing this and why they have these rules can be up to you- are they a cultist under delusions that God is telling them who to kill? Are they some kind of vigilante in their own mind? Do they just do it for fun?

On their latest kill, though, there was a complication- a witness, MC. (Alternatively, YC could take MC and almost kills them but realizes too late they grabbed the wrong person or change their mind). YC's code does not allow them to just kill MC, but they can't let them go, either. Between a rock and a hard place, YC decides the only course of action is to take MC prisoner and keep them in a cage. It's a rather nice, big cage, all things considered. There's even a pillow in it.

~I'll Make A Doll Out Of You~

Main kinks: bondage (heavy), humiliation, kidnapping/obsession/stalking, filming, latex, mindbreak

Pairing: FxF

YC is obsessed with pretty things. Butterflies, flowers, summer drinks- anything colorful, really.

She's also obsessed with MC, the girl next door. Unfortunately, MC dresses in dark colors most of the time- she mars her skin with creepy black tattoos, she wears dark makeup, and she dyes her (short!) hair black.

YC finds this unacceptable, so she kidnaps MC and decides it's her job to fix her. She's going to turn MC from a bratty, rebellious girl into a pretty, obedient blonde little doll to keep on display and serving her one way or another- even if it takes a crotchless pink or skin toned latex suit up to her neck to cover up all those nasty tattoos. She's going to film the whole thing, too, and post it on some shady sites- just in case any other girls out there need help with their dolls.

(This COULD be MxF, as long as it still focuses on the aspect of forced femininity on a nonfeminine woman)

~Revenge is Best Served Cold~

Main kinks: kidnapping, master/pet, slutty clothes, bondage, role reversal

Pairing: A x A

MC was YC's bully in school. They were bigger, stronger, and more popular than YC and liked to wield that power.

Now, years after graduation, YC finds out that MC has…fallen off, for lack of a better term. They're between jobs, couch surfing, and clearly peaked in high school. YC, meanwhile, worked hard and got a great job that has afforded them more than a few luxuries…and the resources to hire someone else to do the dirty work of having MC kidnapped.

When MC comes to, they're surprised to find that nerd they bullied in high school standing in front of him. They're even more surprised to learn what YC has in store: YC thinks they would look great on their knees, and plans to break MC into an obedient, submissive fuck-pet.

~Our Pet Surrogate~

Main kinks: Pregnancy/breeding, kidnapping, master/pet, lactation, age gap

Pairing: MxF(orM)xF

For this RP I would love for you to play a married couple in their 40s. The wife (a nurse) is infertile, but they are desperate for a (at least partially) biological child. IVF is expensive and inconvenient, though, so the two put out an ad asking for a surrogate. This attracts my character, a young, desperate woman turning to anything she can to make money.

(Alternatively this can be an MxM couple wanting a child if we want two men involved, and one of them can be the nurse).

What she doesn't know is that the ad is a trap. She enters the house to discuss the terms of surrogacy and never leaves, ending up locked in their basement and used as their sex toy and incubator, forcibly bred by the husband over and over until she finally falls pregnant, all the while being sexually teased and forced to perform sex acts on the wife as well.

This can be long or short term. I would be willing to time skip around a lot: playing out until she gets pregnant, maybe a few scenes through the pregnancy, and then one or two post-birth when she's being kept as a milk machine for the baby. (The baby can exist as a concept and will not exist in-rp, it was probably taken from her immediately and kept upstairs separate from its parents' depraved actions).

~Shared Property~

Main kinks: kidnapping, master/pet or master/slave, harem (kinda), bondage, multiple main characters 

Pairing: M x F x M x F

For this one, you would play two men and I would play two women. YCs are good friends and roommates, and have been for a while. Recently they opened up to each other about their more forbidden desires and realized that both of them had very similar sexual proclivities they were having trouble finding partners for--both of them are just too controlling and dominant to find women.

Two is better than one. That's what one of YCs thinks when he comes home to find that his roommate has gotten them both a Christmas house gift: two hot young women, tied together and on display under their Christmas tree.

How MCs were acquired and who they are is up for discussion. I do think it might be fun to lean into tropes here and say that they were purchased from an online operation, maybe even as a "two for the price of one" sort of deal. Their relationship to each other is also up for discussion!

Whatever the case, your two men find themselves with two hot, helpless young women–one for each of them, or perhaps to share between both of them.

~Sex Sells~

Main kinks: spitroast, filming/photos, sexual exhaustion

Pairing: MxAxF

For this, you would play two characters. Ideally at least one is a male but we can do it in any configuration really. Your two characters were professional employees for a porn star who recently retired. One was the social media manager and the other did the filming and editing. When their employer retired they realized that with their experience they could easily make any girl a porn star and help her rake in the cash.

But why do that when they could keep the money? If they could get a girl that wouldn't need to be paid and can't say no, well--that's ideal.

YCs purchase a young (18 or 19) virgin woman (MC) from a dark web slave market and have her delivered to their studio. Once she's there, it's pretty simple to start making porn films with her, and with their experience and knowledge of the market, it blows up. They get more 'mainstream' followers, of course, and they set up an OF for her, but the most money comes in from the darker, more secret sites where clients pay thousands for personalized scenes of niche kinks and even more to come over and have a night with her.

This would be a way to explore a bunch of kinks and scenes. If you want a more personal touch then MC could be that star that tries to retire and they kidnap her and force her to keep working, but I liked the idea of them starting fresh with a cash cow that's all theirs with little risk of anyone finding them.

~The Sins of the Father~

Main kinks: kidnapping, bondage, gangbang, humiliation/degradation, free use, reverse harem, sexual exhaustion

Pairing: AxAxAxF

For this, you would play 3 or more individuals that make up the last remaining members of a gang. There will probably be more gang members involved as side characters that both you and I can control as scenes demand.

MC's father is a famous police chief who is renowned for his tough-on-crime attitude. He recently killed the leader and a few members of a local gang in a shootout and jailed several more. YCs, the remaining members, decide that the best revenge is served cold and sink into the shadows for a year, plotting their revenge.

MC is an all-star popular girl. She's a college cheerleader, she's a partier, she's the daughter of the police chief. She has high aspirations and a drive to get those done. All of this is cut short when she's kidnapped.

YCs finally make their move. They capture the mayor's precious daughter (how is up for us to decide) and bring her to their new hideout- which they've been preparing for for a year- where they know she won't be found. Once there, revenge is sweet: the police chief's daughter is now gang property, and they relish in sending him pictures of his precious girl being violated and sexually tortured six ways from Sunday by the very gang he's been trying to take down.

~Stalker's Tango~

Main kinks: stalking/obsession, power dynamics, kidnapping, bondage

Pairing: AxA

MC is obsessed with YC. YC is obsessed with MC. The two of them have been locked in a dance for a while, both stalking the other, both hoping to eventually kidnap and dominate the other. Unfortunately for MC, YC is just a bit faster, stronger, and better. MC slips up. They lose the game of wits and end up locked up and owned by YC, then fucked into submission.

It's fine, though. The object of their desires isn't theirs, per say, but maybe being owned is okay, too. They can make it a fun challenge for YC.

~Making Rent~

Main Kinks: Gangbang, free use, reverse harem, blackmail, humiliation

Pairing: MxMxMxF

For this, you would play three men all sharing a house together. MC is a single woman and their only female roommate.

She falls on hard times after losing her job and comes to them, embarrassed, for help with her rent, and they agree...at a cost. If she wants to stay in the house, they get to fuck her. No limits, no refusals. She does what they tell her to do. As long as she's doing that, and making them home-cooked meals, they'll cover her portion of rent.

Facing homelessness, she reluctantly agrees, and soon finds herself unable to get out of the situation. She's so busy just fulfilling her end of the deal that she can't even look for a new job...and they won't let her leave the house without one of them, anyway.

~FANTASY PLOTS~

Most of these are meant to be high or medieval fantasy, but modern fantasy also works well!

~Rescue Mutt~

Main kinks: master/pet, bondage, nonhuman characters, size difference (small dom, big sub)

Pairing: A x F

MC is a werewolf– a new werewolf, recently turned and then left abandoned and confused. She's been running amok in the woods around her village, trying (and failing) to control her shifts and her instincts. She's half-feral, even in her human form, and completely without a pack.

YC is a vampire. They have ruled over the nearby village for centuries, cultivating their blood-stock and making sure the people there  never get too suspicious. To the village, YC is a strange, wealthy hermit who no one asks too many questions about. So when YC hears about a wolf posing a danger to their village, they of course go out to take care of the problem.

Instead of finding a pack or some young upstart looking to cause trouble, they find one of their own village humans, desperate and confused, feral and hungry. Werewolf blood isn't particularly good for vampires, but MC is large and strong and could be used as a good guard dog and a nice housepet…all she needs is a little guidance, training, and discipline.

~Pretty Bird~

Main kinks: master/pet, bondage, age gap, nonhuman characters

Pairing: A x F

The world this takes place in is one of high fantasy. All sorts of creatures inhabit this realm, but YC is one of the strongest: a dragon. Whether that means they are a dragon who shifts into a fully human form or someone who stays in a halfway/hybrid form is entirely up to you, but they are a dragon. They rule over their domain with an iron fist and demand high tax and tribute from their citizens, but they also protect their realm with the jealous ferocity that their species implies.

MC is a phoenix avian–she would look elven, but would have a tail, wings, and talons at the very least. Phoenixes are extremely rare, valuable creatures, and have to hide their true nature to avoid being snatched up and kept as blood-slaves for their alchemical properties. MC has managed to hide it well for years, but a series of unlucky circumstances find her being gifted to YC by a noble of their court who wishes to rise through the ranks–a phoenix, after all, is something any dragon would be proud to own.

We can talk about further details and worldbuilding possibilities together, I have a ton of ideas for this plot!

~Spoils of War~

Main kinks: master/slave, bondage, exhibitionism

Pairing: F x F

This is the typical, tropey "elf princess gets turned into an orc plaything" plot, because tropes are fun sometimes. MC is an elven princess. Her kingdom has been under attack by YC, a warlord orc woman who is renowned for her battle strategy and strength.

MC is captured by or sold to YC somehow (how that goes down exactly is up for us to discuss). YC is a jealous mistress with a dragon's possessiveness, and she wants every single orc in her camp–and every snooty elven nobleman she meets with–to know that MC is hers, and hers alone.

~Father's Advisor~

Main kinks: blackmail/manipulation, master/slave, bondage, age gap

Pairing: A x A

MC is a monarch, but they ascended to the throne far too early–their father died unexpectedly, and now they are forced to rule a kingdom alone.

YC is MC's late father's advisor, and is now their advisor too. YC sees the struggle MC is facing, all the stress building up, but MC is too stubborn to take their advice. YC decides the best way to get MC under control is through some more…unconventional means.

All it takes is a little manipulation here, some blackmail threats there, and maybe a bit of help with some aphrodisiac bought from the local witch,  and YC has MC on their knees for them. All MC has to do is give up control in the bedroom for them to see that YC has some pretty good ideas, and soon YC has the entire kingdom under their thumb thanks to their puppet monarch who just can't get enough of being dominated behind closed doors.

~SCI FI PLOTS~

~Ship Pet~

Main kinks: abduction, master/pet, gangbang, free use, reverse harem, alien physiology

Pairing: A x A x A x F

MC is a young human woman who is abducted by an alien pirate crew. In this setting, humans would be considered a "lesser" species by most aliens, and while they may acknowledge their sapience, the aliens would probably see them as pets and toys more than people. Humans are newer on the galactic stage and meant to be "protected species", but they are also coveted for the black market pet trade and it's become a status symbol for rich aliens to own a human–especially because of their sexual compatibility with so many different species.

YCs are the small crew of a prolific pirate operation. They have no qualms about breaking laws, and so they abduct MC so they can flaunt her around as the ship's pet. She's well taken care of, even doted over, but that's not much comfort to her when she's also getting fucked six ways from sunday by these creatures that have so much power over her.

It would be interesting if d with a severe language barrier here, where MC is never given a translator and has to decipher how each alien communicates. This plot is very flexible, I think it would just be fun to explore different alien species and how they would interact with a human both sexually and nonsexually.

~Hero, Turned~

Main kinks: kidnapping, master/pet, mindbreak, bondage

Pairing: A x A

MC is a superhero. YC is a supervillain. The two of them have been clashing for years--their powers make them perfect foils for one another, and as such, YC has not been able to get much traction in their plans for taking over the city. That is, until they come into possession of a special drug that is promised to neutralize MC's power.

It works. YC manages to get a lucky shot in a fight with a syringe, and MC is suddenly left without their powers in the middle of a fight with YC. This ends about as well as you'd expect.

When MC comes to, they find themselves still weak, still powerless, and with a collar around their throat. YC is all too happy to explain that the collar keeps the drugs pumping through MC's system, leaving them scarily mortal and feeble. YC is also all too happy to start on their ultimate plan: break MC into the perfect lackey, and force them to help YC's ascent to power.